Proof system
10 mensagem(ns) normal
19/05/2011 11:53
#1
I suggest that when a proof is added, which was asked for, the person asking for the proof has to accept it. I often saw Contrôleur accepting proofs which weren´t acceptable or didn´t proof the record.
19/05/2011 13:45
#2
Impossible because of noob who don't believe a proof of great player and so refuse it.
But we can send a PM to the person who asking, for tell that the score is now proved, and you can check it. If it's not good, create a topic in problem.
But we can send a PM to the person who asking, for tell that the score is now proved, and you can check it. If it's not good, create a topic in problem.
19/05/2011 17:42
#3
Yes but if a player refuses the proof, it could go to the controleur. He checks whether the proof should be refused because of the reasons the player asking for proof gave or if those are not valid and the proof can be accepted. This way the controleur also have less work and we can be more sure, that an accepted proof is good.
19/05/2011 17:54
#4
If I remember, a topic about proof system exist.
It's a good idea to see what the asker thinks of the proof, but only if he have not the last world.
It's a good idea to see what the asker thinks of the proof, but only if he have not the last world.
19/05/2011 18:05
#5
There are a problem in this way too. Multi-account or friends who asked and approve wrong or bad proof, or anything pictures.
19/05/2011 18:19
#6
That´s true, i think what vivien said would be a good solution then.
19/05/2011 18:23
#7
Yeah it look good ;)
20/05/2011 05:57
#8
i think what stl mean is this: http://www.vgr-fr.com/index.php5?c=topic&id=4219&d=0 (and some more score proof problems on vgr)
its nice to see that some recordhunter here are so \"fair\" and posts proofs to there scores but just accept a \"random\" picture of a maybe good known guy/girl looks not that \"profesional\" for vgr. This happen for some of my proofs too(months ago) i did a misstake and upload the wrong pictures for some scores and they are fast accept :o
I mean if im a new guy on this site and see a wrong scores is on place 1, then i dont want to use the site for scores(just for exsample) and i think noone here try to scare ppl to post scores on this site or? ;D
Btw: im a little confused if i see scores here with many ppl playing on it, im the only 1 they try to corecct a wrong score and all oher think: \"hey its prooven, so i cant do anything and i have to live with the score\" ? :/
its nice to see that some recordhunter here are so \"fair\" and posts proofs to there scores but just accept a \"random\" picture of a maybe good known guy/girl looks not that \"profesional\" for vgr. This happen for some of my proofs too(months ago) i did a misstake and upload the wrong pictures for some scores and they are fast accept :o
I mean if im a new guy on this site and see a wrong scores is on place 1, then i dont want to use the site for scores(just for exsample) and i think noone here try to scare ppl to post scores on this site or? ;D
Btw: im a little confused if i see scores here with many ppl playing on it, im the only 1 they try to corecct a wrong score and all oher think: \"hey its prooven, so i cant do anything and i have to live with the score\" ? :/
20/05/2011 13:00
#9
Yes Undead, occasionally STL created topics with scores' problems.
I think a PM is a good idea if you see an error, and a topic for a fake.
Also I understand this is a problem, I'm for a system where we can give our opinion.
And when I accept proofs, I only accept proofs if difficult-level-score is written, or for the game I have, and I'm sure about the proof. I hope the others \"Contrôleur\" did the same thing.
I think a PM is a good idea if you see an error, and a topic for a fake.
Also I understand this is a problem, I'm for a system where we can give our opinion.
And when I accept proofs, I only accept proofs if difficult-level-score is written, or for the game I have, and I'm sure about the proof. I hope the others \"Contrôleur\" did the same thing.
21/05/2011 13:50
#10
Yeah vivien, i trust you that you are careful when approving pictures, but other Controleur don´t, else this problem wouldn´t be here.
Every controleur should be told that he is only allowed to accept a proof when the level/diff is shown or he has the game like you said.
Instead of just having Accept and Refuse there could be a third option for the controleur then, which sends an automated email to the person asking for the proof, if the proof is ok.
What do you think?
Every controleur should be told that he is only allowed to accept a proof when the level/diff is shown or he has the game like you said.
Instead of just having Accept and Refuse there could be a third option for the controleur then, which sends an automated email to the person asking for the proof, if the proof is ok.
What do you think?
You must be logged in to reply to this topic.